ZERO BEAT
Southeastern Massachusetts
Amateur Radio Association, Inc.
54 Donald Street
South Dartmouth, MA  02748


  Volume 43, Issue 3

SEMARA

- W1AEC

March 2007  

440 MHz Amateur Radio vs. USAF

By Richard J. Cabral, W1RJC

Communications as we know it on the 70 centimeter (440 MHz) amateur band are slowly changing in our region. For decades, the FCC has allocated the United States Air Force (USAF) as primary and amateur radio as secondary on this 420–450 MHz band. What this means is government related usage takes precedence over amateur use. In certain areas of the country, amateurs are restricted to no more than 50 watts output power in order to prevent interference to these primary users.

Locally, the 50 watt output power restriction is in place due to the Otis Air National Guard Base located within the Massachusetts Military Reservation on Cape Cod. They operate a missile warning and space surveillance system called PAVE PAWS. PAVE is an Air Force program name, while PAWS stands for Phased Array Warning System. PAVE PAWS basically sends pulses across the entire band at thousands of watts through a special phased array antenna.

If you have ever operated on the 440 band locally and heard a lot of “snap, crackle and pops” on weaker signals (most notably on users operating through repeaters), chances are you were hearing the effects of PAVE PAWS transmissions. The PAVE PAWS system at Otis AFB is one of only three in operation in the U.S., with the other two being Beale AFB, California, and Clear Air Force Station, Alaska. In each of the three locations, a 50 watt restriction on 440 is in place within a set mile radius of the AFB.

PAVE PAWS Radar Screen
PAVE PAWS Radar Screen

Nuclear Warning System Map
Nuclear Warning System Map

Up until the last few years, amateurs have successfully shared the 440 band with the USAF without much problem in New England. This began to change about 4 years ago however, when the USAF requested a ban on amateur use for a section of the 440 band. The New England Spectrum Management Council (NESMC) was notified that hams in Maine, Massachusetts, New Hampshire and Rhode Island must discontinue using 439.150 – 441.250 MHz. A few links and repeaters were forced to change frequency and re-coordinate. This restriction was put in place by the request of the Millstone Hill Digisonde (radar system), which is owned and operated by the US Air Force Research Laboratory (AFRL) at Hanscom Air Force Base in Bedford, MA.

The next round of changes followed in the summer of 2006 and remains on going. NESMC was notified of over a dozen 440 repeaters within an 80 mile radius of Otis AFB that is causing interference to their PAVE PAWS system. As of March 2007, the USAF has sent proof of the interference to the FCC, and it is expected that a decision will be made soon on what action will need to be taken.

Realistically, there are three possible decisions that the FCC may reach. In our favor, the FCC may allow the repeaters in the affected areas to remain on the air. Secondarily, they may allow the repeaters to remain on the air, but be required to change frequency. Worst case scenario is that the FCC can order all the repeaters affected to cease and desist completely, forcing them to shut down and not operate anywhere on the 440 band.

All of these restrictions draw one question to the amateur community in New England. Why are amateur transmissions on 440 suddenly causing harmful interference to USAF stations that have peacefully co-existed with us for decades? In a search of the FCC web site, there appears to be no current information on this on going issue. Likewise, calls I made to Otis AFB has remained unanswered. We will just have to wait and see what the FCC’s decision will be. Despite the hardship to amateurs, the fact remains that we are secondary operators on 440 and the FCC has every right to grant precedence to the USAF.

Related links of interest:

Pave Paws: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PAVE_PAWS

NESMC: http://www.nesmc.org

FCC: http://www.fcc.gov

 

CONTENTS
PAGE 1
PAGE 2
PAGE 3
PAGE 4
PAGE 5
PAGE 6
PAGE 7
PAGE 8